As Paul Tenorio wrote,
If you go to an MLS regular season game today and your team loses, it doesn’t feel like it matters. Will this [playoff format] really change that? Will it feel in the moment like a game of consequence?
I understand and largely agree with the larger point. I actually hate that so many teams make the playoffs. It's not a reward for elite performance if two-thirds of the teams qualify. I would prefer four or six teams from each conference make it. But I really disagree with the notion that there's no pressure on regular season games. It is not the same pressure as exists in promotion/relegation situations, but it is pressure nonetheless. I found my game this weekend to be a prime example.
It paralleled one of the most memorable calls in my career 15 years earlier, when my Dynamo team was getting such poor results on the road that home games felt like our only chance for a win. Most people at the time didn't understand why I was so exuberant as to yell, "WOOHOO!" following a stoppage-time goal in a late-August regular season game. But I knew *at the time* (to Paul's point) that the difference between a 7-point week and a 5-point week was significant. I was right: That 2-point standings bump wound up giving us home-field advantage in our conference semifinal playoff series.
Similarly, Charlotte FC has only one road win this year. They are hoping for a top-four finish and home-field advantage in the conference quarterfinals. In a three-game week against three teams below them in the standings (Columbus, Toronto, D.C. United), their 3-3 tie on Wednesday night in Toronto was similar to my 2011 Houston team's midweek draw at New England, a team we unequivocally should have beaten. In both cases, the midweek result upped the pressure on Saturday's game, because taking only 5 points from three favorable matchups was just unacceptable.
It's not "your contract will be canceled because the club will drop to a lower division" pressure, I'll grant you. But it is pressure, knowing you only have five home games left in which you're confident of taking the full three points.
The game itself, which I called alongside Manchester United legend Phil Neville, certainly had pressure. It may have been stultifying pressure, in fact, in the first half. But it led to high drama in the second, and it felt like we largely got the calls right. Have a listen!





